Composting Toilet vs Porta Potty

Composting Toilet vs Porta Potty: How to Choose Between the Two

Choosing between a composting toilet vs porta potty waste disposal system is an important decision for anyone who is considering an alternative to flush toilets. They both offer advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to understand the differences before making a decision.

In this article, we’ll explore the differences between the two, the advantages and disadvantages of each, how to choose between them, how to live with them comfortably, and what to keep in mind. 

Disclosure: Best Composting Toilet, as an Amazon Associate, earns commissions on qualified purchases. This informative review article may contain affiliate links. Commission and earnings support our work. This means we may receive a commission if you purchase items from links embedded in the articles.

Last update on 2024-07-04 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Why Use Alternative Non-Flush Toilets? 

For many people, a standard flush toilet is an accepted and preferred choice for dealing with making waste. However, there are many reasons why a non-flush toilet such as a composting toilet or porta potty would make more sense.

For starters, the cost of a flush toilet is relatively high compared to other options. Additionally, flush toilets use a significant amount of valuable water in order to work properly, an issue of particular importance in water-starved areas. Furthermore, depending on the local sewer system, human waste can often end up in unhealthy and dangerous places, whereas with a composting toilet, the waste can be composted in a healthy and safe environment.

What Is a Composting Toilet?

A composting toilet is a type of toilet that produces compost by breaking down and decomposing human waste with the help of bacteria, fungi, and other microorganisms. Composting toilets provide an ecological, economical, and low-maintenance way of dealing with human waste. 

Unlike the traditional flush toilet which relies on the costly and energy-intensive process of sophisticated plumbing and water treatment systems; composting toilets use a more natural method of dealing with waste. The standard composting toilet uses a system of separation of liquid and solid waste. The “dry” solid materials are placed in an airtight container, which is then covered with a layer of peat moss or coco coir to create a carbon-rich environment that helps promote the breakdown of organic material.

When the composting process is complete, the waste materials can be used as fertilizer or soil conditioner for gardens and plants, or in some cases, for agricultural purposes. Composting toilets are ideal for use in locations such as camping sites, parks, and resorts, as well as in residential settings.

Composting toilets has a variety of benefits to both the environment and the user. By not having to dispose of the waste in a sewage system, they reduce water usage and waste production substantially. Additionally, the natural composting process helps to reduce carbon emissions. The compost created can also be used to fertilize plants and gardens, reducing the need for chemical fertilizers. Additionally, composting toilets are low-maintenance and require very little cleaning and cost.

There are multiple types of composting toilets available. Self-contained composting toilets are the most basic type and use a single chamber for collecting and processing waste. These are the most economical type, but require the user to manually empty the compost bin periodically. Centralized systems are more complex, with the separate collection and processing chambers. These systems generally require the use of a vacuum or auger to transport waste from the collection chamber to the processing chamber and also require an exhaust fan for venting odors.

Overall, composting toilets are a great alternative to traditional flush-type toilet systems and are becoming increasingly popular due to their environmental benefits, low cost, and maintenance requirements. Composting toilets can provide a sustainable, ecological option for dealing with human waste while still providing convenience, hygiene, and comfort.

What Is a Porta Potty?

A porta potty, or portable toilet, is one of the most commonly used units in the world. From construction sites to special events and anywhere in between, portable restroom rentals have become a necessity in certain areas. Porta potties are self-contained, clean, and convenient when access to facilities is not permanent or too far away for easy access.

The purpose of a porta potty is simple; to provide temporary and relatively hygienic access to a restroom and/or toilet. They come in a variety of sizes, shapes, and even colors, and are especially convenient when hosting an event or in the case of an emergency. Porta potties are a great solution for providing a safe and sanitary restroom experience away from permanent facilities.

The core component of a porta potty is its strong yet lightweight, portable tank. This tank is filled with a mixture of fresh and reclaimed water. Fresh water is refilled as needed, while reclaimed water is used in the same manner. Additionally, each porta potty has a tank for storing waste, and this tank is emptied and replaced with a fresh one regularly. Depending on the size of the tank, it can hold up to one month’s worth of waste before needing to be replaced.

Porta potties also come with a variety of features including handrails, air fresheners, and a dual-flush toilet for odor control. Special requirements for accessibility, such as wheelchair access and handrails, can often be added to the units. In addition, porta potties are also available with a variety of waste disposal systems, including chemical, manual, and recycling systems.

Porta potties should always be placed away from any high-traffic areas or where they could be tampered with or vandalized. Additionally, it is important to ensure that any ground surface is level where the portable toilet is placed, as an unstable porta potty can become a potential hazard. They should also be anchored well, as strong winds can cause the toilets to tip over and become damaged.

Overall, porta potties are invaluable for quickly and conveniently providing access to restrooms and toilets when permanent facilities are unavailable. From large-scale events to temporary construction sites, portable restroom rentals offer convenience, comfort, and a safe sanitary experience. These units are mainly used to provide a hygienic and comfortable restroom experience, and when used and maintained properly, they are essential in keeping the area clean and odor-free.

Last update on 2024-07-04 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Advantages & Disadvantages of Each

Composting Toilets and Porta Potties are both increasingly popular solutions to many household and commercial waste management problems. Both provide effective and discreet ways of disposing of physical waste, but there are certain advantages and disadvantages to each of them. 

First, let’s take a look at choosing a composting toilet vs porta potty system. Composting toilets use aerobic bacteria to break down organic material, like waste, into compost. Compost is a great natural fertilizer that can be used to enrich the soil and make it healthier. The composting process also greatly reduces the smell and pollutants associated with conventional waste disposal methods. One of the major advantages of using composting toilets is that they produce very little waste, which can make them more environmentally friendly compared to other types of toilets. Additionally, compost itself can be a valuable resource, as it can be used to improve soil fertility and can even be used as a fuel source. 

One of the main disadvantages of composting toilets is that some types require large amounts of energy and resources in order to keep the composting process going. For example, some systems require electric power or natural gas to keep the composting process going. Additionally, the compost produced can take a long time to fully break down, meaning the period for when it can be used is long.

PortaPotties are essentially temporary toilets – they are typically used in outdoor events and are intended for short-term use. The main advantage of using porta potties, compared to composting toilets, is that they require little or no setup and require minimal resources to maintain. They can be quickly and easily installed and can be taken down just as quickly when no longer needed. Additionally, they require almost no maintenance, meaning that they can be taken up and moved with ease.

However, one of the biggest drawbacks of porta potties is that they are often the source of immense amounts of waste, as the waste disposal process associated with porta potties is often done inefficiently and often creates a considerable amount of pollution. Additionally, porta potties often have a risk of health hazards, as they can often lead to the spread of diseases. Additionally, the waste from porta potties often contains toxic chemicals that can be dangerous if not properly disposed of.

Overall, it is important to consider the advantages and disadvantages of both composting toilets and porta potties when deciding which one to use. Composting toilets are often the more environmentally friendly option, as they produce less waste, but can be expensive and require more resources to maintain. Porta potties, on the other hand, require minimal maintenance and can be quickly set up and taken down, but often produce more waste. Ultimately, the choice between the two should depend on the situation, budget, and short and long-term goals.

How to Choose Between the Two 

When deciding between the two, the main considerations should be cost, convenience, and environmental factors. If cost is not an issue, a composting toilet is probably the better choice. It offers more environmental benefits and requires less maintenance than a traditional flush toilet.

If cost is a major factor, then a porta-potty is likely the better choice. It is much cheaper than a composting toilet and can be installed and moved easily. However, a porta potty does not break down the waste like a composting toilet, so there can be more odors, mess, and risk of disease if it is not maintained properly.

Things to Keep in Mind

When considering the two options, it is important to bear in mind that with either choice, there will be some ongoing maintenance requirements. Composting toilets will need to be tended to, and porta potties will need to be emptied and cleaned regularly.

Additionally, both types of toilets require electricity in order to operate. Composting toilets rely on fans and pumps, while porta potties rely on an electric pump to empty out their waste.

How to Live With These Types of Toilets Comfortably

Living with a composting toilet or a porta potty is relatively simple. For starters, it is important that all users of the toilet understand how it works and follow the proper guidelines for using it. Additionally, using biodegradable toilet paper, and ensuring the toilet is regularly cleaned and maintained will help to keep the toilet smelling fresh.

When using a composting toilet, be sure to use a liner for the compost bins, so that the waste is not in direct contact with the bin. Regularly turning and stirring the compost will help it to break down faster. Additionally, setting up a fan system and a vent to the outside will help to reduce any odors that may arise.

For a porta potty, it is important to empty the tank regularly, to prevent any buildup of unpleasant odors. Additionally, it is important to clean and disinfect the toilet regularly, to help prevent the spread of disease.

Last update on 2024-07-04 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


Composting toilets and porta potties provide convenient and cost-effective solutions for dealing with waste. Choosing a composting toilet vs porta potty system is better for the environment since it would break down the waste into a usable form of compost, while porta potties provide a cheap and convenient solution for outdoor events.

When deciding between the two, it is important to consider the cost, convenience, and environmental factors, as well as the ongoing maintenance that will be required. Understanding how to use and live with each type of toilet comfortably will also help to ensure a pleasant experience.