Composting Toilet vs Septic Tank

Composting Toilet vs Septic Tank: Which is Best for Your Situation?

The growing concern over climate change and the need to protect our planet has made non-flush toilets more popular than ever. Composting toilets and septic tanks are two of the most widely discussed non-flush toilets, but what are the differences between them, and which is best for you? That’s the question we aim to answer with this article.

We’ll start by discussing why one should choose a composting toilet vs septic tank system and then move on to provide an in-depth comparison of composting and septic tanks. We’ll cover the advantages and disadvantages of each, how to decide between them, important things to keep in mind when living with non-flush toilets, and the ways you can live comfortably with them.

Disclosure: Best Composting Toilet, as an Amazon Associate, earns commissions on qualified purchases. This informative review article may contain affiliate links. Commission and earnings support our work. This means we may receive a commission if you purchase items from links embedded in the articles.

Last update on 2024-05-23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Why Use Alternative Non-Flush Toilets?

When it comes to non-flush toilets, there are many environmental and economic benefits. Non-flush toilets have been proven to save large amounts of water a year, which is especially beneficial if you live in an area facing water scarcity or drought. Non-flush toilets also have a smaller environmental footprint, as they don’t use energy-intensive water pumping systems, and they don’t require flushing of waste.

Additionally, they often require less maintenance than traditional flushing toilets, making them more cost-effective in the long term. Furthermore, non-flush toilets can provide an upgrade to your home’s aesthetic by providing a cleaner, more pleasant bathroom experience. 

What Is a Composting Toilet?

Composting toilets are an ecological alternative to traditional toilets, transforming human waste into a rich fertilizer for gardens and sustainable plant growth. The process of composting involves decomposing organic matter, such as human excrement, which is exposed to air and moisture and using beneficial microorganisms to break down the waste into safer, nutrient-rich soil. 

Composting toilets offer many advantages over traditional sanitation systems. Traditional toilets rely on piped wastewater systems and require large amounts of energy to maintain. In contrast, composting toilets are self-contained and require minimal water, energy, and maintenance. Additionally, composting toilets lower environmental impact by reducing water waste and minimizing the production of sewage, which leads to fewer pollutants in the environment. 

Composting toilets may be categorized into two basic types, depending on the composition of the composting material used: aerobic and anaerobic. Aerobic composting relies on aerobic bacteria, which thrive in oxygen-rich conditions, to break down organic matter. The breakdown process produces heat, accelerating the decomposition and reducing odor. 

Anaerobic composting also requires organic matter, but anaerobic bacteria, which thrive without oxygen, carry out the decomposition process. Because anaerobic bacteria don’t generate heat, it takes longer for the decomposition process to occur. While anaerobic composting produces less-refined nutrient-rich soil, it does not produce odors. 

Both types of composting toilets use the same components. A receptacle holds the solid waste and separates it from the liquid waste. There may be a urine separator that retains the urine in a separate container. During the composting process, a beneficial carbon material, such as coconut fiber, wood shavings, or sawdust, is added to absorb moisture and help in the decomposition process. A fan and/or filter provides air circulation and odor control. Finally, a container collects the decomposed compost and fertilizer. 

When properly installed and maintained, composting toilets can provide a safe and sanitary solution for treating human waste. The composted material is rich in nutrients, which makes it ideal for use in gardening, landscaping, and agricultural applications. The end product of composting toilets is a much cleaner, safer, and more efficient way to dispose of human waste, benefiting both people and the environment.

What Is a Septic Tank?

Choosing a composting toilet vs septic tank system isn’t for everyone, and septic tanks can be more beneficial.

A septic tank is a traditional non-flush toilet system that uses water to flush waste away. When talking about septic tanks, it’s important to first explain what they do. Simply put, they are an underground storage system that collects and processes wastewater from a home or business. They not only collect the wastewater, but they also treat it, storing it in a tank until it is safely disposed of through drainage into the ground. 

The tanks can be made of various materials, however, most are constructed with concrete, fiberglass or plastic. The capacity of the tanks depends on the size of the house and the number of people living there. A smaller tank size is usually sufficient for a two-person household whereas a larger tank may need to be installed for a four-person or larger household. 

Septic tanks are usually the first line of defense when it comes to protecting the environment from the release of untreated wastewater. The tank collects wastewater from the home, separating it into three sections – solids, scum, and liquid. The solids sink to the bottom, creating a sludge layer, the scum floats on top and the liquid is found in between those two layers. That liquid portion is then drained into a separate pipe, allowing it to disperse naturally into the ground. 

The natural bacteria in the tank help to break down the organic matter like detergents, food waste, grease, and human waste. It is then slowly released into the ground where soil acts as a filter, trapping any additional solids and returning only the treated wastewater back into the environment. It’s important to maintain the septic tank with regular maintenance, such as pumping and cleaning the tank to ensure it does not overflow or become clogged. 

The benefits of having a septic tank are numerous. For example, it saves a lot of money in the form of municipal sewer fees, as sewage treatment is provided within each individual property. It also provides a better and more reliable form of wastewater treatment, since it is done on-site and can be monitored closely. 

Furthermore, a septic tank is an environmentally beneficial system as its use conserves energy and water. By using wastewater treatment within the home or business, energy resources are saved since sewage is not transported to and from a treatment plant. The wastewater is also reused, as the water filtered through the tank can be used for activities such as watering the garden. 

To sum it up, septic tanks are underground storage systems that collect and treat wastewater from homes and businesses. They are usually made of concrete, fiberglass, or plastic and the capacity of the tanks depends on the needs of the household. Septic tanks provide numerous benefits such as cost savings, better treatment, and environmental advantages. Regular maintenance should be done on the tank in order to ensure its proper functioning and longevity.

Last update on 2024-05-23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Composting Toilet Disadvantages

The main disadvantage of a composting toilet is that the compost produced must be treated with a sanitizer or deodorizer before it is suitable for use in a garden or as soil amendment. Additionally, composting toilets often require more frequent maintenance than septic tanks and can require ventilation systems to manage the odor. 

Septic Tank Disadvantages

The main disadvantage of a septic tank is the fact that it requires water to function, making it less eco-friendly than a composting toilet. Additionally, septic tanks require frequent maintenance and may need to be emptied periodically, as well as service for issues such as clogs and overflow. Furthermore, septic tanks may require a large area for installation, making them less suitable for smaller properties. 

How to Choose Between the Two 

When choosing between a composting toilet and a septic tank, there are a few factors to consider. Firstly, you should determine your budget and the size of your property, as this will determine which type of toilet is most suitable for your needs. Additionally, if you live in an area with water scarcity, then a composting toilet may be the best option due to its waterless operation. You should also consider the amount of maintenance and upkeep that each type of toilet requires in order to ensure that it meets your needs. Finally, you should also consider the environmental factors of each option, as septic tanks are often more harmful to the environment due to their reliance on water. 

Things to Keep in Mind 

When living with a composting toilet or septic tank, there are a few things to keep in mind. Firstly, it’s important to remember that both options require maintenance and upkeep. With a composting toilet, it’s important to ensure that the environment stays warm, dry, and ventilated, as this will allow the aerobic bacteria to thrive. With a septic tank, it’s crucial to ensure that the tank is properly maintained and serviced. Additionally, both types of non-flush toilets require special cleaning agents and toilet paper, as traditional products can clog the systems. 

How To Live With These Types Of Toilets Comfortably 

Living with a non-flush toilet can be a challenging yet rewarding experience. Firstly, it’s important to ensure that you have the right setup and that you are using the appropriate products. Additionally, it’s important to keep up with maintenance and to address any issues as soon as possible. With a composting toilet, it’s especially important to keep the environment warm, dry, and ventilated. Finally, it can be helpful to use items such as deodorizers and chlorine tablets to help maintain a pleasant smell. 

Last update on 2024-05-23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


In conclusion, both composting toilets and septic tanks are excellent options for those looking for a non-flush toilet. Choosing a composting toilet vs septic tank system is ideal for those living in areas with water scarcity, as they require no water and are relatively easy to maintain. Septic tanks, on the other hand, are more suitable for those who prefer the traditional flushing experience.

Ultimately, the choice between a composting toilet and a septic tank depends on a number of factors, such as budget, size of the property, and environmental impact. With this article, we hope that you have a better understanding of the differences between composting toilets and septic tanks, and are able to make the best decision for your needs.